Monday, April 24, 2006

The Damned Narnians

This week's Entertainment weekly article on Walden Media got me thinking. Walden seems to be building a family-friendly brand in "Walden Media." From what I've read, they're hoping that in a couple years people will hear that something is a Walden Media film, and they'll take their family, if for no other reason, other than they know it will be kid-friendly and faithful to a children's classic.
I think they're ducking a potential PR nightmare since the Narnia stories become increasing exclusivist in their Christian worldview...and who could blame them. LWW was clearly a Christian tale, but non-Christians can leave appreciating the Jesus-like salvation myth while still feeling as their alternative faith was untouched. In future novels, however, it becomes clear that Aslan is not the only holy being the creatures in Narnia have faith in. And according to Aslan, these other faiths are all based on a lie and the people who follow the lie are lost. As I'm sure you know, there's a big difference between telling a Jesus story in a magical world and telling stories which portray false religions in that magical world...especially when the other major religion in that world is patterned on Islam. Mind you, I think as far as Christian exclusivists go, CS Lewis is fairly respectable in his portrayal of the other religions. But in today's world, any worldview that appears intolerant is met by the public with a harsh (and ironically, intolerant) backlash.
Walden's big brand: Narnia, however, is building its own lucrative fanbase. The unanswered question is, how much of that fanbase will remain loyal if the Narnia stories start saying, "if you're not a Christian, you're going to hell." To many Christians, that's true, non-offensive, and not at all in conflict with the family-friendly brand of Walden Media. For this segment of the fanbase, to remove the "offensive" elements would be a betrayal by Walden of their commitment to "remain faithful to the text"...a line they repeated out over and over during the LWW campaign so to avoid the religion question. To many others (both non-Christians and more liberal Christians), keeping those elements in is about as un family friendly as you can get.
I think it's clear that the Narnia brand and the Walden Media brand are steam rolling towards one another. Walden must have a plan for how to handle this, but since they're not being open about it, I'm guessing they haven't figured out any great compromise or anything and that ultimately, they plan on pissing off one of these two groups.
Prince Caspian doesn't hit this sub-theme as much as the next story, The Dawn Treader, and later stories do. If Caspian doesn't make a big financial splash, I can see producers balking and not being willing to go out on a limb and offend people since to do so would mean they could lose a portion of their dwindling audience. It'll be interesting to see how long Walden Media will be willing to sing its "we're faithful to the text" mantra.
At this point what I find so fascinating is that the major media outlets haven't pondered this question yet. Given that LWW made more money domestically than Harry Potter 4 did last year, I thought at least one major entertainment correspondent would have spent the one day required to crank out the Narnia series and see what they're all about (I think all seven of them together are slimmer than Harry Potter 5) . Had they done so, I'm sure they would have had a big story titled something like "Is CS Lewis' Narnia good for today's kids" around the time of the DVD release. Oh well. At some point they'll figure it out...and it'll be fun to watch.

1 Comments:

Blogger Tim said...

You know I don't see this as that big of a problem for them. I think they'll stick to the script just like with the last one. Some people can take it as a fantasy and others can take it as an allegory for Christianity. I think the average moviegoer is going to see it for the fun fantasy and they won't care how this all relates. Christians will watch and smile. Others (i.e. Muslums, Hindus, ect) who know what's really going on might get pissed and make a big deal, but it will just make the movie "controversal" and give the movie more press.
I think Da Vinci Code is in the same boat. Pissing religious sects off is a great way to get people talking about your movie.

4/30/06, 8:57 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home