Poland's X3 Review

But I'm going to counter by pointing out that your faith in Ratner's abilities would cloud your judgment so much that even if this movie sucks...which apparently it doesn't...you would still defend it, claiming you alone understood it's inner beauty...but I think your defense would also be in large part due to your refusal to believe that the anti-Ratner bandwagon may be on to something.
X-Men: The Last Stand is a real Brett Ratner movie.
And by that, I mean that it is endlessly flawed, ham-fisted in many ways, but still has enough flourishes to get away with it. Not every Brett Ratner film is as successful a film as this one. There were moments when I considered whether this is his best film. It may be. But it is really too flawed to allow the word “best” to be used in reference to it. Yet, it doesn’t suck.
The best thing in the film is crystal clear. And that is Famke Janssen’s Phoenix character. She is the only element of the film that succeeds on both a physical/effects and emotional level. Ironically, she has almost no dialogue. In that arena, the show stealer, as was inevitable, is Sir Leigh Teabag (aka Sir Ian McKellen), as the leader of the loyal opposition....
The script and directing also fails to put together even a Super Friends TV cartoon level of the mutant team working together. It may have been terrible animation, but whatever Superman did led to what Aquaman did to what Batman did to what Wonder Woman did. And when those Wonder Twins turned into stuff, it was always helpful stuff. Every mutant gag here seemed to be a standalone. And perhaps the greatest opportunity for a superhero screenwriter ever, a kid who is “one of them,’ a mutant, but one whose power is to short circuit the power of whoever he is near and only for as long as he is close. This is the magic conceit every screenwriter dreams of… except for these two, apparently.
Still, I can’t say that I was ever in pain or that I disliked the experience. I would be very interested in seeing the Phoenix scenes again.

1 Comments:
Who says that the mutants powers have to work together to overcome a challenge? Why do they have to do that for it to be a good movie? When it comes to mutant powers I just like it when they do clever things with their abilites which they did quite a bit in the last one.
As far as Ratner goes, I am in no way a die hard fan. The only movie of his that I really liked was Red Dragon. That movie is the only reason why I believe he'll be able to pull X3 off. Yeah, I saw "After The Sunset" and it was awful. I walked out. The reason, I think X3 is going to be so good is because the trailers look amazing. That's the real reason why I'll see this opening weekend.
Post a Comment
<< Home