The Power of History
This is one of the best things I've read in defense of the Iraq War. It's clear, concise, and reveals that although Bush's attackers like to pull select pre-war quotes from Bush, they don't want you to remember what they said pre-war.
This guy doesn't argue that everything's gone perfectly...I think only an idiot would try to argue that. But what Wehner does make a strong case for is that Bush's opponents are pointedly taking advantage of people's short-term memory.
In his novel 1984, Orwell describes one of Big Brother's most prominent and potent tactics as re-writing history to suit it's own political desires; if this isn't a clear case of the leadership of the American Left's tendency to be like Big Brother, I don't know what it.
According to Moses, the biggest danger the Israelites faced when leaving Egypt wasn't starvation in the desert or being killed by an enemy army, it was forgetting their history. I'm not asking anyone to agree with my political point of view...I'm simply asking people to remember their history as it happened and not follow the lead of the Israelites who, a couple weeks after the Red Sea event, were convinced by Aaron that the parting of the waters had occurred because of the power of a golden calf. People have always been predisposed to believing alternative histories...we should guard against falling into that trap.
Revisionist History: Antiwar myths about Iraq, debunked. BY PETER WEHNER
Tuesday, May 23, 2006
http://www.opinionjournal.com/editorial/feature.html?id=110008415
Some excerpts...read the whole story for quotes from Pelosi, Kennedy, Dean, Clinton, and Kerry.
BTW, saying that Bush is like Big Brother too, doesn't justify or negate the Left's immoral actions as accounted above.
This guy doesn't argue that everything's gone perfectly...I think only an idiot would try to argue that. But what Wehner does make a strong case for is that Bush's opponents are pointedly taking advantage of people's short-term memory.
In his novel 1984, Orwell describes one of Big Brother's most prominent and potent tactics as re-writing history to suit it's own political desires; if this isn't a clear case of the leadership of the American Left's tendency to be like Big Brother, I don't know what it.
According to Moses, the biggest danger the Israelites faced when leaving Egypt wasn't starvation in the desert or being killed by an enemy army, it was forgetting their history. I'm not asking anyone to agree with my political point of view...I'm simply asking people to remember their history as it happened and not follow the lead of the Israelites who, a couple weeks after the Red Sea event, were convinced by Aaron that the parting of the waters had occurred because of the power of a golden calf. People have always been predisposed to believing alternative histories...we should guard against falling into that trap.
Revisionist History: Antiwar myths about Iraq, debunked. BY PETER WEHNER
Tuesday, May 23, 2006
http://www.opinionjournal.com/editorial/feature.html?id=110008415
Some excerpts...read the whole story for quotes from Pelosi, Kennedy, Dean, Clinton, and Kerry.
Iraqis can participate in three historic elections, pass the most liberal constitution in the Arab world, and form a unity government despite terrorist attacks and provocations. Yet for some critics of the president, these are minor matters. Like swallows to Capistrano, they keep returning to the same allegations--the president misled the country in order to justify the Iraq war; his administration pressured intelligence agencies to bias their judgments; Saddam Hussein turned out to be no threat since he didn't possess weapons of mass destruction; and helping democracy take root in the Middle East was a postwar rationalization. The problem with these charges is that they are false and can be shown to be so--and yet people continue to believe, and spread, them...
Thanks to the bipartisan Silberman-Robb Commission, which investigated the causes of intelligence failures in the run-up to the war, we now know that the President's Daily Brief (PDB) and the Senior Executive Intelligence Brief "were, if anything, more alarmist and less nuanced than the NIE" (my emphasis). We also know that the intelligence in the PDB was not "markedly different" from that given to Congress.
...the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence's bipartisan Report on the U.S. Intelligence Community's Prewar Intelligence Assessments on Iraq. Among the findings: "The committee did not find any evidence that intelligence analysts changed their judgments as a result of political pressure, altered or produced intelligence products to conform with administration policy, or that anyone even attempted to coerce, influence or pressure analysts to do so."...
Upon his return from Iraq, weapons inspector David Kay, head of the Iraq Survey Group (ISG), told the Senate: "I actually think this may be one of those cases where [Iraq under Saddam Hussein] was even more dangerous than we thought."...
President Bush argued for democracy taking root in Iraq before the war began. To take just one example, he said in a speech on Feb. 26, 2003: "A liberated Iraq can show the power of freedom to transform that vital region, by bringing hope and progress into the lives of millions. America's interests in security, and America's belief in liberty, both lead in the same direction: to a free and peaceful Iraq. . . . The world has a clear interest in the spread of democratic values, because stable and free nations do not breed the ideologies of murder. They encourage the peaceful pursuit of a better life. And there are hopeful signs of a desire for freedom in the Middle East. . . . A new regime in Iraq would serve as a dramatic and inspiring example of freedom for other nations in the region."
The following day the New York Times editorialized: "President Bush sketched an expansive vision last night of what he expects to accomplish by a war in Iraq. . . . The idea of turning Iraq into a model democracy in the Arab world is one some members of the administration have been discussing for a long time."
BTW, saying that Bush is like Big Brother too, doesn't justify or negate the Left's immoral actions as accounted above.

4 Comments:
I don't think anyone would disagree that a democracy in the middle east is needed. The things that were/are going on over there were pretty awful, but they are awful ALL over the world. If Bush/ Cheney didn't have so much personally to gain by controling Iraq it would be a great humanitarian effort. But everyone knows that they do have a shit load of personal intrest in this war and that they aren't doing it because it is going to make the world better. I feel that the fact that good things are going to happen from this is just a side note to how much money they stand to and are gaining. And it's unfortunate that it's costing us 285 billion dollars to help them along. Oh yeah, and that 40,000 Iraq civilians have died and their rate of death goes higher and higher everyday. And don't forget the 2,500 American soldiers who have also died. Many who don't believe in it.
As I read your comment I thought your major, if not only, problem with the war was the administration's apparent conflict of interests. But then you stated that it has costed us $285B so far. Correct me if I'm wrong, but the fact that it costs that much doesn't bother you (assuming it actually brings freedom to the Mideast), right? It's the idea of spending that much money on a Bush/Cheney power play that bugs you...or am I missing something?
Thanks for your post.
Yes, that is my major problems with the war. Freedom under a tyrant is great, but you know what? It would be great in Korea too, which many people believe gives the U.S. an even bigger threat. Shouldn't we be over there liberating their people and disarming a psychopath too? I don't think we are because the administration doesn't have a personal interest to do that.
China's been able to consistantly talk with Korea...we shouldn't invade them. You're right in saying that they're a bigger threat...but just because they're bigger doesn't mean you invade. In fact, them having nukes means if we invade we may lose the city of Anchorage. That would be bad. As long as diplomacy has any chance, we should go for it.
Post a Comment
<< Home