the Departed
So I watched this movie again. I watched it again because I didn't really like it the first time. It wasn't a bad movie, but I kept comparing it to Infernal Affairs and it kept coming up short. Then, with its wins at the Oscars and trailers that make it look like it should be my number one movie of all time (which reminds me, I have a friend at work who bought the DVD when it came out even though he hadn't seen the movie yet. He said, "With it winning best picture, a great line up and previews that made it look just awesome, I knew I'd love it." Which he did). So I watched it again and I had the same feelings. Leo was phenomenal, Damon was real good, Whalberg was "ehh", Nicholson was interesting even though I could never really figure him out, but my favorite person, (who never even gets mentioned that he's in the movie) was Alec Baldwin. Every time he spoke he cracked me up.Anyway, with that being said, the psychiatrist love triangle was stupid. There was no reason for her and Leo to ever get together. And I'm sorry, the suspenseful scenes aren't anywhere near as good as they were in Infernal Affairs. This movie is a lot like Infernal Affairs but the things that were changed should not have been. I give this movie credit for its style and acting but besides that, Infernal Affairs win in every other category. If you haven't seen it, SEE IT. It's a great film and I'm sure you'll agree that it's better then this years Best Picture.

4 Comments:
I saw The Departed twice in the theater and loved it both times. What you say is interesting...i have a feeling that if I did see Internal Affairs, I would still like Departed better. Once you see one movie (or read a book) the other movie is never as good. You've already given your heart away...there's not much love left to give.
That is usually the case but not always. I think that if you saw Infernal Affairs you would agree with me.
BTW your "given your heart away" line was the cutest thing I've ever read. It definitely had me laughing.
So I got an email from Tony who finally got around to taking me up on my recommendation to watch the Departed. Here's what he said.
"I finally watched The Departed yesterday. Maybe I let all the hype raise my expectations too high, but I wasn't all that overwhelmed. It was an ok movie, probably better than most, but I don't think it was anything special. The acting was average, except for Jack; the plot wasn't especially strong or interesting; the characters were superficial, underdeveloped, and unlikable (a Harvard-educated psychiatrist who winds up dating not one but TWO patients? Is Hollywood unaware that this would very probably lead to her losing her license to practice?); and the lead "Irish" badguy had an Italian last name. O, and when Martin Sheen was killed? Police officers do not merely let suspects flee the scene of a felony because the radio guy tells them to. I can find nothing about this film to recommend it to be nominated for an Oscar, much less to win. The more I think about it, the less I care for this film. In fact, I now revoke the "probably better than most" comment above."
In most, if not all, cases he's very much right. It's amazing how for some of us we totally suspend our disbelief without questioning, but in other cases, for who knows why, we get hung up on finer points that in other movies wouldn't bother us.
You know, you guys are right, we do suspend or disbelief for some things but not with others. I think let it slide sometimes for a number of reasons.
#1 How unbelievable the situation is.
#2 If we are enjoying the movie or not.
#3 What happens next after the unlikely event. For this let me give you an example. In The Departed when Martin Sheen falls off the roof and Damon is telling his guys not to go after the suspects, the one cop just goes "Fuck this", jumps out of the car and shoots a dude in the chest. THEY DIDN'T EVEN SEE THE "BAD GUY" DO ANYTHING! Anyway, I remember thing "yeah, right", but right after I was thinking "oh shit, here comes a shoot out!" and totally forgot about how unbelievable it was that the cop would just jump out and start shooting like that. Do you see what I mean? Maybe it's just me and I'm quick to forget, but yeah, if the film makers bend reality for a second so that something I'm interested in can happen, I'm all for it.
Post a Comment
<< Home