Okay, I just got back from the movie. Loved it! I almost did what I thought I was going to do, which is walk out. I thought I was going to get really bored and then the movie would do something stupid and I would leave right then. I was
so close. (If only Eric and Ann have seen this, I'm sorry but...) You know the one scene where Barry Pepper is laying on the bed and that lady throws the hot coffee on him and bashes the pot across his nose and then goes, "Now we're even." Yeah, I thought that was terrible. Right then I was thinking, okay I know exactly how this movie is going to end. Everything the evil border patrol man did earlier is going to come back and get him, he'll be all changed, repent and life will be beautiful. I thought
for sure that this was going to happen. Then I thought, well, I wonder how they are going to deal with Tommy Lee Jones character, Pete. Are they going to have him be arrested, killed, or glorified? I thought, well there is like a half hour/forty five minutes left, I might as well just see how it ends. So I'm watching it and something happened. I don't know if I've ever seen something so profound about a character, yet so simple. Okay here it is...Tommy Lee Jones is sitting at the bar waiting for that waitress to call him.
Rachael: Where are you?
Pete: I'm in Mexico. I want you to come down here with me.
Rachael: What?
Pete: I want you to come down here. We can get married and grow old together.
Rachael: No I won't come to Mexico with you. Are you crazy?
Pete: Why not?
Rachael: Because I'm married that's why?
Pete: But you said that you loved me.
BAM! Right there I saw Pete in a whole new light. He's not the cliched, quiet, old but rough ranch hand. He's just a guy who doesn't understand people. He didn't get that this is something she just says to people to be affable. He doesn't get people, but he got Melquiades and in the end of the movie we find out that Melquiades probably was the same way. Nobody even knew who this guy was. He too was a lonely guy who just wants to live life the best way he can.
On another note Barry Pepper really impressed me in this movie. I haven't seen him since 25th Hour. He did a great job of getting the shit beaten out of him. Oh my GOD! He got pistol whipped, slapped, bitten by a snake, his foot cut open, dragged through a lake by his neck, burnt his feet, had hot coffee dumped on him and got hit in the face with a pot. Not to mention he had to dig a bunch of graves and had to deal with the smell of a rotting corpse for like five days. Poor guy.
Now, I didn't think Tommy Lee Jones did such a good job directing. This movie would have been in my top ten had a better director been on it. There were some scenes that should have been cut, some acting that should have been improved and one scene where I wasn't sure what the hell to think (the one where the old man asks them to shoot him).
Overall, really really liked it. The more I think about it the better it is. Should it have gotten a scene play nomination? I agree with Eric, I don't think so, but I don't agree with most of the nominations they give out.